TheRound TableGuide — 食鉴

Method

How We Rate

Chinese cooking has its own vocabulary of excellence. We score in that vocabulary, not in translation.

Five criteria, 1–5 points each

火候

Technique

Control of heat, timing and execution.

味道

Flavor

Depth, balance and clarity of seasoning.

口感

Texture

Mouthfeel — the bounce, crunch and silk Chinese cooking prizes.

食材

Ingredients

Quality, freshness and sourcing.

地道

Authenticity

Fidelity to the region and its tradition.

Total possible: 25 points.

Three tiers

家常Neighborhood

15–18

points

招牌Premier

19–22

points

大师Distinguished

23–25

points

Restaurants scoring below 15 are not listed.

五行 · The five elements

Each restaurant earns 0 to 5 element badges for what its kitchen does exceptionally well.

火

Fire

Wok hei, chili, the heat of the stove.

水

Water

Soups, steaming, seafood, hot pot.

木

Wood

Vegetables, tofu, tea.

金

Metal

Dumplings, dim sum, noodles, knife work.

土

Earth

Braises, claypot, home-style cooking.

五行俱全

All five elements complete — awarded to a restaurant that earns every element badge.

Heritage

地道 Heritage

An optional mark for rare, authentic regional cooking seldom found outside its home province.

Worth the 7 Train

A 1–5 dot score: how worthwhile the trip to Flushing is from elsewhere in the city.